Ethereum is everything?
Regulators can’t agree on a single classification for Ethereum — technically, it’s a security, currency, and commodity.
This creates a dilemma of sorts for the world’s second-largest cryptocurrency by market capitalization.
Ether’s versatility and wide functionality set it apart from the crowd, although this makes it difficult to define.
Despite this, it does not suffer from an unclear classification, even while the United States Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) may still lay claim to regulate it.
Without a strict classification, Ether potentially avoids extensive securities, commodity, or currency-specific regulations, which could slow its adaptation in the world of innovation.
Source: cointelegraph
Ethereum – Security
In the United States, the Howey test determines whether an asset is a security by assessing whether it meets the criteria for “investment.” The test consists of four conditions: money investment, joint venture, profit expectation, and profit based on someone else’s work. If a transaction meets all of these criteria, it is classified as a security and is subject to appropriate regulations. Looking through this test, Ether meets these requirements during its initial public offering (ICO) in 2014. Investors invested money, shared resources were managed by the Ethereum Foundation, and the expectation of profits was high. But as the network became more decentralized, the SEC changed the classification in 2018, concluding that Ether was no longer dependent on a centralized entity and therefore no longer had to be considered a security, even though it met all the requirements of the Howey test.
Source: cointelegraph
Ethereum – Currency
Currencies are used as a means of payment and have legal recognition within the financial system.
In Japan, Ether is a legally accepted means of payment, but the question arises – does this make it a currency in the traditional sense?
According to the standard definition, a currency must meet several conditions: be a medium of exchange, a unit of account, a store of value, and legal tender.
Ether is used as a medium of exchange in transactions within numerous DApps (decentralized applications) and platforms, and is used to assess the value of services and goods within its ecosystem.
Also, many hold it as an investment, which gives it the role of a store of value.
However, Ether is not legal tender in most countries, which distinguishes it from traditional currencies such as the dollar or the euro.
Although Ether is used similarly to a currency, the lack of government recognition limits its full integration into traditional definitions of currency.
Source. Cointelegraph
Ethereum – commodity
While Ether is often classified as a security or currency, it is also classified as a commodity, particularly by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) in the US.
While this may seem unusual at first glance, it is completely in line with the approach that the CFTC applies to certain digital assets like Bitcoin.
Ether meets the key requirements for commodities – it is fungible, holds value and is actively traded on global exchanges.
Its lack of a central issuer also distinguishes it from securities, as Ether operates on a decentralized network.
Trading Ether on futures markets further cements its status as a commodity.
However, while Ether meets current regulatory frameworks, the future development of the crypto market could trigger changes in this classification due to challenges in regulating decentralized digital assets.
Source: cointelegraph
So what is Ethereum?
At its core, Ether can fit all or none of these definitions at the same time.
The key problem lies in the lack of a comprehensive global regulatory framework for cryptocurrencies, which forces regulators to adapt existing laws to these new digital assets.
Considering the pros and cons of each classification – security, currency, or commodity – the closest definition to Ether is currently a commodity.
While not perfect, this framework allows for market regulation, investor protection, and integration with traditional markets.
Nevertheless, Ether has more functionalities, but its primary role corresponds most closely to the characteristics of the commodity.
Source: cointelegraph
The Future of Ethereum Classification
Until a complete, globally applicable regulatory framework tailored to the unique characteristics of digital assets is in place, the classification of Ether as a commodity will have to be a satisfactory solution. This approach provides a structured regulatory but temporary solution until more comprehensive regulations are adopted. An example of such a new regulatory framework is the European Crypto-Asset Markets Regulation (MiCA), which classifies crypto-assets into different categories, and Ether would belong to the group of “other crypto-assets.” This approach allows for a balance between innovation, market stability, and consumer protection, which helps the development of the Ethereum ecosystem while ensuring the necessary security measures are in place. While not a perfect solution, MiCA is an important step forward that other countries could follow in the future. We hope you enjoyed today’s blog, and that you learned something new. If you have any questions or suggestions, you can always contact us on our social networks (
Twitter, Instagram).